Communities

Writing
Writing
Codidact Meta
Codidact Meta
The Great Outdoors
The Great Outdoors
Photography & Video
Photography & Video
Scientific Speculation
Scientific Speculation
Cooking
Cooking
Electrical Engineering
Electrical Engineering
Judaism
Judaism
Languages & Linguistics
Languages & Linguistics
Software Development
Software Development
Mathematics
Mathematics
Christianity
Christianity
Code Golf
Code Golf
Music
Music
Physics
Physics
Linux Systems
Linux Systems
Power Users
Power Users
Tabletop RPGs
Tabletop RPGs
Community Proposals
Community Proposals
tag:snake search within a tag
answers:0 unanswered questions
user:xxxx search by author id
score:0.5 posts with 0.5+ score
"snake oil" exact phrase
votes:4 posts with 4+ votes
created:<1w created < 1 week ago
post_type:xxxx type of post
Search help
Notifications
Mark all as read See all your notifications »
Q&A

Post History

#3: Post edited by user avatar Tim Pederick‭ · 2023-05-09T10:08:09Z (over 1 year ago)
Tweak wording.
  • One is a chance of doing something. The other is a chance of *having a chance* of doing something.
  • Here are some analogies that may or may not help, depending on your familiarity with the kinds of situations described.
  • ---
  • Analogy 1: A tabletop roleplaying game (RPG).
  • Your character is sneaking down a dungeon corridor. Unfortunately, you neglected to check for traps, and a poison dart flies out of a concealed hole. You roll the dice to avoid it, but you only have **a 25% chance** of succeeding at dodging it.
  • This is the “25% chance of avoiding injury”. $P\left(\mathrm{uninjured}\right)=0.25$.
  • Having learned your lesson, you start checking for traps as you go. Good thing too, as there’s a pitfall trap straight after the dart trap. The game master secretly rolls your search result; there is **a 25% probability** that you see it. If you don’t, you automatically fall in. If you do see it, you still have to roll your **chance of avoiding it**.
  • This is the “25% probability that there was a chance of avoiding injury”. $P\left(\mathrm{uninjured}\right)=0.25x$, where $x$ is your chance of succeeding on that second roll.
  • ---
  • Analogy 2: The lottery ticket
  • You and three friends buy a lottery ticket together. For some reason, you don’t want to split the prize (if any). Instead, you randomly choose which of you gets any winnings. There is **a 25% chance** that the recipient is you.
  • This is the “25% chance of avoiding injury”. $P\left(\mathrm{recipient} ight)=0.25$.
  • But of course, you don’t know if there *will* be any prize coming. There’s **a 25% probability** that you’re the chosen recipient, but you still have to wait until the lottery is drawn before you know what you could receive. Your ticket probably only has a small **chance of <strike>avoiding injury</strike> winning a prize**.
  • This is the “25% probability that there was a chance of avoiding injury”. $P\left(\mathrm{winner} ight)=0.25x$, where $x$ is the chance of the lottery ticket winning something.
  • One is a chance of doing something. The other is a chance of *having a chance* of doing something.
  • Here are some analogies that may or may not help, depending on your familiarity with the kinds of situations described.
  • ---
  • Analogy 1: A tabletop roleplaying game (RPG).
  • Your character is sneaking down a dungeon corridor. Unfortunately, you neglected to check for traps, and a poison dart flies out of a concealed hole. You roll the dice to avoid it, but you only have **a 25% chance** of succeeding at dodging it.
  • This is the “25% chance of avoiding injury”. $P\left(\mathrm{uninjured}\right)=0.25$.
  • Having learned your lesson, you start checking for traps as you go. Good thing too, as there’s a pitfall trap straight after the dart trap. The game master secretly rolls your search result; there is **a 25% probability** that you see it. If you don’t, you automatically fall in. If you do see it, you still have to roll your **chance of avoiding it**.
  • This is the “25% probability that there was a chance of avoiding injury”. $P\left(\mathrm{uninjured}\right)=0.25x$, where $x$ is your chance of succeeding on that second roll.
  • ---
  • Analogy 2: The lottery ticket
  • You and three friends buy a lottery ticket together. For some reason, you don’t want to split the prize (if any). Instead, you randomly choose which of you gets any winnings. There is **a 25% chance** that the recipient is you.
  • This parallels the “25% chance of avoiding injury”. $P\left(\mathrm{recipient} ight)=0.25$.
  • But of course, you don’t know if there *will* be any prize coming. There’s **a 25% probability** that you’re the chosen recipient, but you still have to wait until the lottery is drawn before you know what you could receive. Your ticket probably only has a small **chance of winning a prize**.
  • This parallels the “25% probability that there was a chance of avoiding injury”. $P\left(\mathrm{winner} ight)=0.25x$, where $x$ is the chance of the lottery ticket winning something.
#2: Post edited by user avatar Tim Pederick‭ · 2023-05-09T08:35:08Z (over 1 year ago)
Added a second analogy.
  • One is a chance of doing something. The other is a chance of *having a chance* of doing something.
  • Imagine a tabletop roleplaying game. Your character is sneaking down a dungeon corridor. Unfortunately, you neglected to check for traps, and a poison dart flies out of a concealed hole. You roll the dice to avoid it, but you only have **a 25% chance** of succeeding at dodging it. $P\left(A\right)=0.25$.
  • Having learned your lesson, you start checking for traps as you go. Good thing too, as there’s a pitfall trap straight after the dart trap. The game master secretly rolls your search result; there is **a 25% probability** that you see it. If you don’t, you automatically fall in. If you do see it, you still have to roll your **chance of avoiding it**. $P\left(A ight)=0.25x$, where $x$ is your chance of succeeding on that second roll.
  • One is a chance of doing something. The other is a chance of *having a chance* of doing something.
  • Here are some analogies that may or may not help, depending on your familiarity with the kinds of situations described.
  • ---
  • Analogy 1: A tabletop roleplaying game (RPG).
  • Your character is sneaking down a dungeon corridor. Unfortunately, you neglected to check for traps, and a poison dart flies out of a concealed hole. You roll the dice to avoid it, but you only have **a 25% chance** of succeeding at dodging it.
  • This is the “25% chance of avoiding injury”. $P\left(\mathrm{uninjured}\right)=0.25$.
  • Having learned your lesson, you start checking for traps as you go. Good thing too, as there’s a pitfall trap straight after the dart trap. The game master secretly rolls your search result; there is **a 25% probability** that you see it. If you don’t, you automatically fall in. If you do see it, you still have to roll your **chance of avoiding it**.
  • This is the “25% probability that there was a chance of avoiding injury”. $P\left(\mathrm{uninjured} ight)=0.25x$, where $x$ is your chance of succeeding on that second roll.
  • ---
  • Analogy 2: The lottery ticket
  • You and three friends buy a lottery ticket together. For some reason, you don’t want to split the prize (if any). Instead, you randomly choose which of you gets any winnings. There is **a 25% chance** that the recipient is you.
  • This is the “25% chance of avoiding injury”. $P\left(\mathrm{recipient}\right)=0.25$.
  • But of course, you don’t know if there *will* be any prize coming. There’s **a 25% probability** that you’re the chosen recipient, but you still have to wait until the lottery is drawn before you know what you could receive. Your ticket probably only has a small **chance of <strike>avoiding injury</strike> winning a prize**.
  • This is the “25% probability that there was a chance of avoiding injury”. $P\left(\mathrm{winner}\right)=0.25x$, where $x$ is the chance of the lottery ticket winning something.
#1: Initial revision by user avatar Tim Pederick‭ · 2023-05-01T23:58:01Z (over 1 year ago)
One is a chance of doing something. The other is a chance of *having a chance* of doing something.

Imagine a tabletop roleplaying game. Your character is sneaking down a dungeon corridor. Unfortunately, you neglected to check for traps, and a poison dart flies out of a concealed hole. You roll the dice to avoid it, but you only have **a 25% chance** of succeeding at dodging it. $P\left(A\right)=0.25$.

Having learned your lesson, you start checking for traps as you go. Good thing too, as there’s a pitfall trap straight after the dart trap. The game master secretly rolls your search result; there is **a 25% probability** that you see it. If you don’t, you automatically fall in. If you do see it, you still have to roll your **chance of avoiding it**. $P\left(A\right)=0.25x$, where $x$ is your chance of succeeding on that second roll.