Communities

Writing
Writing
Codidact Meta
Codidact Meta
The Great Outdoors
The Great Outdoors
Photography & Video
Photography & Video
Scientific Speculation
Scientific Speculation
Cooking
Cooking
Electrical Engineering
Electrical Engineering
Judaism
Judaism
Languages & Linguistics
Languages & Linguistics
Software Development
Software Development
Mathematics
Mathematics
Christianity
Christianity
Code Golf
Code Golf
Music
Music
Physics
Physics
Linux Systems
Linux Systems
Power Users
Power Users
Tabletop RPGs
Tabletop RPGs
Community Proposals
Community Proposals
tag:snake search within a tag
answers:0 unanswered questions
user:xxxx search by author id
score:0.5 posts with 0.5+ score
"snake oil" exact phrase
votes:4 posts with 4+ votes
created:<1w created < 1 week ago
post_type:xxxx type of post
Search help
Notifications
Mark all as read See all your notifications »
Meta

Post History

60%
+1 −0
Meta Should there be more than one sort of math community?

1 answer  ·  posted 2y ago by whybecause‭  ·  last activity 2y ago by Monica Cellio‭

Question feature-request
#2: Post edited by user avatar whybecause‭ · 2021-12-30T23:51:27Z (about 2 years ago)
  • There are, to my mind, two very different but important kinds of mathematical question. There is the kind that the Codidact and SE communities both like: Straight-forward "give the proof/calculation" questions. This can be "How do I solve this?" or "Why is this wrong?" or a few other variations.
  • But there are "soft" math questions that are not about the math itself but about the philosophy of math ("Is math invented or discovered?"), or the psychology of math ("When I see a problem like this, what methods or theorems should I think of to solve it?"), or for book recommendations, and so on. Of course the Codidact and SE communities both strongly discourage these questions. It's understandable in that they are often harder to answer.
  • BUT that doesn't mean that they are bad questions, or that one shouldn't ask them, or that there aren't good answers, or that a community shouldn't exist to help with them.
  • I can see reasons why maybe Codidact might not want to take on the challenge of hosting a community for these kinds of questions. It will probably have a low answer-acceptance rate, it will probably be prone to debate and therefore difficult to moderate, and so on.
  • So I understand if we ultimately don't want to have such a community. But I just wanted to bring up the possibility and see what people's thoughts are.
  • There are, to my mind, two very different but important kinds of mathematical question. There is the kind that the Codidact and SE communities both like: Straight-forward "give the proof/calculation" questions. This can be "How do I solve this?" or "Why is this wrong?" or a few other variations.
  • But there are "soft" math questions that are not about the math itself but about the philosophy of math ("Is math invented or discovered?"), or the psychology of math ("When I see a problem like this, what methods or theorems should I think of to solve it?"), or for book recommendations, and so on. Of course the Codidact and SE communities both strongly discourage these questions. It's understandable in that they are often harder to answer.
  • BUT that doesn't mean that they are bad questions, or that one shouldn't ask them, or that there aren't good answers, or that a community shouldn't exist to help with them.
  • I can see reasons why maybe Codidact might not want to take on the challenge of hosting a community for these kinds of questions. It will probably have a low answer-acceptance rate; it will probably be prone to debate and therefore difficult to moderate; Codidact is small and other features are probably higher-priority to implement, I suppose.
  • So I understand if we ultimately don't want to have such a community. But I just wanted to bring up the possibility and see what people's thoughts are.
#1: Initial revision by user avatar whybecause‭ · 2021-12-30T23:50:27Z (about 2 years ago)
Should there be more than one sort of math community?
There are, to my mind, two very different but important kinds of mathematical question.  There is the kind that the Codidact and SE communities both like: Straight-forward "give the proof/calculation" questions.  This can be "How do I solve this?" or "Why is this wrong?" or a few other variations.  

But there are "soft" math questions that are not about the math itself but about the philosophy of math ("Is math invented or discovered?"), or the psychology of math ("When I see a problem like this, what methods or theorems should I think of to solve it?"), or for book recommendations, and so on.  Of course the Codidact and SE communities both strongly discourage these questions.  It's understandable in that they are often harder to answer.  

BUT that doesn't mean that they are bad questions, or that one shouldn't ask them, or that there aren't good answers, or that a community shouldn't exist to help with them.  

I can see reasons why maybe Codidact might not want to take on the challenge of hosting a community for these kinds of questions.  It will probably have a low answer-acceptance rate, it will probably be prone to debate and therefore difficult to moderate, and so on.  

So I understand if we ultimately don't want to have such a community.  But I just wanted to bring up the possibility and see what people's thoughts are.